So, one of my supervisors recently suggested that I should look into the influence / impact of porn on intimacy; that essentially intimacy had become 'pornified'. I thought it sounded like a fair assumption to make, there are a few adult-dating sites out there, such as Adultmatchmaker and Ashleymadison that I'm sure feminist critique would label as having a negative impact on relationships...Indeed, as people like Adam Turpin (2006) and Pamela Paul (2005) would have you believe, society is more or less "pornified", and that men in particular are "wired for porn", an addictive force not unlike heroin use or binge drinking.
A fellow postgraduate student of mine (thanks Joy!) over the weekend linked me to a BBC production called 'Websex: What's The Harm?' (2012), a tongue-in-cheek documentary which purports to give "a revealing look at the growing trend of young people initiating sexual relationships on the internet and mobile devices. What are they risking? What are the boundaries?". It revolves around recent research concuted by Andy Phippen over at the University of Plymouth, who argues that an alarmingly high number of young people in their teenage years are using the internet, and their mobile devices, for casual sex.
However, as I have learnt there are recent critics of the pornification theses and the moral panic. Academics and researchers such as Jacobs (2007), Lumby & Albury (2010), Paasonen (2011), and Smith (2010) have labelled it as being reductive, overly negative and caught in a binary mode of thinking. They argue that the internet, and porn, have changed the way sex and sexual identity is expressed.
I thought that there would be something widely cited on the link between porn and online dating (particularly from the pornification angle, perhaps even a feminist critique which lambasted the way in which men hiding behind a screen treat online female daters with little respect), but so far I have found nothing. If I'm to be honest, the section on the sexualisation/pornificiation of intimacy is, I believe, my weakest part to the literature review so far. If you know of some research that's more along the line of how porn influences the way men and women negotiate dating websites, let me know, because that's essentially my train of thinking, I just don't see anything out there along that line.
References
BBC 2012, Web Sex: What's The Harm?, accessed 09/08/2012, http://www.abc.net.au/iview/#/program/24626
Jacobs K, Pasquinelli M, Jannsen M 2007, C'Lick Me: A Netporn Studies Reader, Paradiso, Netherlands
Paul,
P 2005, Pornified: How Pornography Is Transforming Our
Lives, Our Relationships, and Our Families,
Henry Holt and Company, USA.
Paasonen, S 2011, Online Pornography: Ubiquitous and Effaced, The Handbook of Internet Studies, Mia Consavlo and Charles Ess (eds), Wiley-Blackwell, USA.
Turpin, A 2006, 'Not Tonight Darling, I Am Online', FT.com, accessed 10/08/12, http://search.proquest.com.ezproxy.uow.edu.au/docview/228992003
Hi Matt
ReplyDeleteHow advanced is the sociological/social psychological subfield which studies the links between multimedia forms and social behaviour? If the subfield is still in its infancy or is relatively newly emerging, could research and theoretical thinking around the niche area of pornography and sex as a discourse still be developing within broader literature in the field of media/behaviour?
Irrespective of specific discussions on sex and behaviour, it would be interesting to know what literature broadly on media and behaviour suggests its more salient effects are on structures of behaviour at a higher abstract level. The literature could, especially if it comes from a socio-biological or constructivist perspective more broadly, discuss the implications of media for gendered behaviour. How does the study of sex fit with broader implications derived from studies of media and behaviour?
Sounds like the subfield of sex and behaviour could very well be something you and Joy are shaping and developing now!
Peter Lalli
Hi Matt,
ReplyDeleteDuring one of my increadibly demanding study sessions examining representations of hipster masculinty thorugh the lens of Vice magazine, i can me accross an article that might be of use to you.
This story provides a brief introduciton to the "Edgeplay" community: A group of people who basically make BDSM look like vanilla sex. The part that I thought might interest you is the way that this community has taken their interests online, to sites like Fetlife. Essentially using new media and online spaces to develop, talk about and exchange (intimate?) experiences. according to this article, the potenital illegality of thier intersts is one reason behind this -as BDSM is not permitted in some countires, and the issues relating to concent and absence of 'safewords'.
I know this group is a little left field, particularly considering your two existing case studies, but it might be worth checking out.
Hannah
here's some bits to get you started:
http://www.vice.com/read/edgeplay-isnt-your-grandmothers-bdsm-scene
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FetLife
Hey Hannah,
ReplyDeleteI love it (not Edgeplay, but the machinations behind it, driving it online)! I've only given it a cursory glance but the principal is basically there - that there seems to be privileged intimacies, and that subordinated intimacies (through deviance, race, sexuality) seem to be pushed into fringe areas online.
Enlighten me, what is Vice magazine about, typically? You're not an "edgeplayer", are you?? Hah.
Matt
Hi Matt,
ReplyDeleteyeah It did cross my mind that this might be a risky topic to publish online. sorry to disapoint you all, but no, i'm not into edgeplay. ^-^
Vice magazine is a hipster staple, the US version has been around for quite a while, but the Australian one pales in comparison. one might say; "its tote pathetic".
THe magazine tries to engage in the trendy, the underground, and above all; the hip. its like the General Pants of the media world.
So this article would be more of a one-off attempt to engage in a subculture, than be a typical subject of discussion amoungst Vice readership.
Glad to be of help. And don't worry, I won't be offended if you don't take it on. I'm sure the wet suids and blood drinking was entertainment enough to validate my post.
I did read it! I don't think I can use it in the honours thesis though, but if I get the grades for the phd it's all useful stuff in documenting online intimate spaces. I'll have to have a look into fetlife at some point. An ethnographic study of fetlife...Well, at the very least I'll learn some new words!
ReplyDeleteI was expecting to come away from that appalled - but I actually came away expecting more hahaha.
Actually, what was that doing in a hipster zine? Is it down to edgeplay being 'totes non-mainstream' ?